The Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin According To Women

by

Table of Contents

Shaving can be very harsh to the skin over time, even more, if you have a sensitive type of skin. The constant dragging of sharp razors across your skin can cause irritation, redness, and razor bumps.

The solution?

Get yourself a good shaving cream that uses natural ingredients and free from harmful substances, like phthalates and parabens. If you want some good recommendations, here’s our review for the best shaving cream for sensitive skin that women approve.

Comparison Table For The Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin

Shaving Cream

Image

Size

Scent

1. Kiss My Face Moisture Shaving Cream

>>No.1 Choice<<

3.4 oz

Fragrance-free

Check Price

2. Nurture My Body Shave Cream

4 oz

Fragrance-free

Check Price

​3. CREMO Unscented Shave Cream

4 oz

Unscented

Check Price

​4. Van Der Hagen Shave Butter

6 oz

Light buttery fragrance

Check Price

​5. Pacific Shaving Co. Caffeinated Shaving Cream

3.4 oz

Spearmint

Check Price

6. Majestic Pure Shaving Cream

4 oz

Subtle Sandalwood

Check Price

7. Eos Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

7 oz

Unscented

Check Price

8. Whish Lemongrass Shaving Cream

5 oz

Lemongrass

Check Price

9. Now Solutions Nutri-Shave Natural Shave Cream

8 oz

Light citrus scent

Check Price

10. IntiMD COOCHY PLUS Intimate Sh​​ave Cream

8 oz

Parfum

Check Price

Top 10 Reviews For The Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin

1. Kiss My Face Moisture Shaving Cream - Editor’s Choice

 Check The Best Price

Pamper yourself to moisturizing satisfaction as you shave with this shaving cream from Kiss My Face. This moisturizing shaving cream is fragrance-free to suit even the most sensitive skin. It promises to provide a smooth and close shave on your legs, face, and armpits.

Here are the highlighted features of Kiss My Face Moisture Shaving Cream:

  • This shaving cream is developed with a 4-in-formula to soften, smooth, sooth, and moisturizes sensitive skin.
  • It uses natural ingredients such as olive oil, coconut oil, golden seal, lemongrass, and aloe vera. Olive oil and coconut oil moisturize the skin while lemongrass and aloe vera soothe the skin. Golden seal helps shield your skin from nicks and scratches.
  • It contains no harmful ingredients, such as phthalates, parabens, and artificial fragrances. It’s gluten-free, vegan-friendly, and not tested on animals.
  • It works well with double edge safety razors and straight edge razors.

The only downside about this product is the price which is a bit expensive. But given its quality, it’s a smart investment.

PROS​

  • Contains no harmful ingredients
  • Gives a smooth, close shave
  • All natural and fragrance-free
  • Lather-less for great visibility
  • Moisturizes, soothes, softens, and soothes the skin

CONS

  • A bit expensive

2. Nurture My Body Shave Cream

 Check The Best Price

The Best Non-Foaming Cream

Another gentle shaving cream that you can use for your sensitive skin is the Nurture My Body Shave Cream. This non-foaming cream is great for shaving your legs, face, and underarms. It’s free from dangerous chemicals and artificial fragrances.

Here are the features that make Nurture My Body Shave Cream a good investment:

  • Nurture My Body uses lubricating emollients to prevent the skin from irritation and razor burn. The emollients also help moisturize and soften the skin.
  • It uses plant-based ingredients such as coconut oil, dandelion root, and plantain.
  • The shave cream comes with a recyclable, UV-proof blue glass jar. The lid is made of recyclable PET plastic.
  • This product receives the EWG Rating of zero, which is the lowest rating for ingredient hazard score. This means the shaving cream contains no hazard ingredients. It contains no parabens, sulfates, and synthetic fragrances.
  • This is a non-foaming cream so you only need to use a thin layer of the product to shave.

As for the downside, this shave cream comes in a fat jar. You need to dive your fingers directly into the jar just to get a small amount of the product. This means possible contamination of germs to the product.

PROS​

  • Offers a smooth shave
  • Excellent EWG ratings
  • Recyclable glass jar
  • Fragrance-free and organic

CONS

  • It would have been better if it comes in a tube or pump

3. CREMO Unscented Shave Cream

 Check The Best Price

The Best Shaving Cream For Problem Skin

If your skin is prone to breakouts, then the CREMO Unscented Shave Cream might be a good solution. It has a skin-clearing formula that can help fight blemishes, razors, and ingrown hairs. It’s unscented so it’s great for sensitive skin.

Here are other features that make CREMO Unscented Shave Cream a good try:

  • Skin clearing formula helps prevent your skin from nicks, ingrown hairs, and razor burns. Ingredients include salicylic acid, papaya fruit extract, and allantoin.
  • The slick formula offers you a close shave that leaves your skin feeling and looking smooth and soft. When combined with water, It allows your blade to glide easily over the skin.
  • The 4 oz contents can last you for up to two months of use. It’s concentrated so you only to use a small amount.

As for the downside, this shave cream is a bit thicker than other shaving creams in the list. To thin it out, dilute it with water.

PROS​

  • Prevents ingrown hair and razor burns
  • No additional synthetic fragrances
  • Works with practically any blade
  • Comes with a good price

CONS

  • A bit thick

4. Van Der Hagen Shave Butter

 Check The Best Price

​The Best Shaving Cream In A Bundle

Now, if you want to stock a lot of shaving creams to last you for many months, the Van Der Hagen Shave Butter might be a good choice. This shaving butter comes in three 6-ounce bottles which equal to 18 ounces of high-quality shave formula. It has a light fragrance so it works great even for sensitive skin.

Here are the features that make Van Der Hagen a good shaving cream for your sensitive skin:

  • It’s made of natural ingredients such as shea, mango, and cocoa butter. This rich formula protects your skin from nicks and cuts while keeping it moisturized.
  • It creates a very thin layer on your skin, allowing your razor to move smoothly.
  • It contains no soap so it won’t foam like customary shave creams out there.
  • It includes more than 10% of glycerin to naturally comfort your skin.

Since this is enriched with emollients, it might clog your pores. This is bad news for those with oily skin. To prevent any breakouts, dry your skin off after shaving and apply a fragrance-free lotion.

PROS​

  • Reduces skin dryness
  • Comes with three 6-oz bottles
  • Lets the razor glide smoothly over your skin
  • Light, pleasant fragrance

CONS

  • Not ideal for oily skin

5. Pacific Shaving Co. Caffeinated Shaving Cream

 Check The Best Price

​The Best Shaving Cream For Travel

One of the banes in traveling is to have your favorite shaving cream seized at the airport. The Pacific Shaving Co. Caffeinated Shaving is available in travel-friendly sizes so it can pass at the airport without any problem. It’s made of safe ingredients and perfect for women with sensitive skin.

Here are the features of the Pacific Shaving Co. Caffeinated Shaving Cream:

  • This shaving cream is Transportation Security Administration (TSA) compliant, meaning that you can bring it in your carry-on bag without being stopped by airport security.
  • It’s made of safe and natural ingredients, such as spearmint essential oil, aloe, and naturally-derived caffeine that helps reduce redness. The spearmint gives a nice cooling effect.
  • It contains no artificial fragrances and parabens. It’s vegan and not tested on animals.
  • It’s available in a 3.4-oz tube. The concentrated formula can last up to 100 shaves.

As for the downside, this shaving cream may gunk up your razor blade cartridge. If you want to use this product, make sure that you replace the razor blades after each shave.

PROS​

  • TSA-compliant for travel
  • Free from harmful ingredients
  • Gentle cooling effect
  • Helps decrease the sight of redness

CONS

  • May gunk up on the razor blade cartridge

6. Majestic Pure Sandalwood Shaving Cream

 Check The Best Price

The Best Unisex Shaving Cream

If you want a shaving cream for both your man and yourself, then the Majestic Pure Shaving Cream might be a good option. This shaving cream is formulated with natural ingredients to soothe the sensitive skin of both men and women. Its gentle formula suits all types of hair and skin.

Here are the other features of the Majestic Pure Sandalwood Shaving Cream:

  • It’s professionally made with sandalwood essential oil to help comfort your skin, reduce irritation, and keep it feeling cool. It also includes other natural ingredients, such as aloe, grape seed oil, and vegetable-based glycerine.
  • This product is cruelty-free and never been tested on animals.
  • No need water! Simply lather this shave cream with a shaving brush or with your hands.

If you have super dry skin, this shaving cream might not be good for you. It sorts of dries out your skin when you apply it for shaving.

PROS​

  • Has a refreshing scent
  • Gives a comfortable shave
  • Sandalwood essential oil offers a lot of skin benefits
  • Can reduce inflammation

CONS

  • May dry the skin

7. Eos Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

 Check The Best Price

The Best Shaving Cream For Dry Skin

If your skin is dry and sensitive, then the eos Shave Cream might be all you need. It’s made with natural butter and oils to moisturize your skin without leaving any oily residue. It’s safe for sensitive skin because it’s unscented.

Here are the best features of the eos Shave Cream:

  • It’s enriched with natural butter and oils, like shea butter, mango butter, and coconut oil to help moisturize your super dry skin. Other natural ingredients include aloe, cucumber seed oil, and wild oat.
  • Its slick cream is free from gluten, phthalates, and parabens. It’s hypoallergenic, fragrance-free, and dermatologist-tested to be safe for sensitive skin.
  • It works on normal hair type and recommended for sensitive skin.
  • Its low-foam formula goes a long way. It can last up to more than 100 shaves.

Since this shave cream is thick, it’s difficult to wash it off from your razor. You need to clean the blade thoroughly or change it after each shave.

PROS​

  • Moisturizes and soothes the skin
  • Free from harmful ingredients, like paraben and phthalates
  • Hypoallergenic and dermatologist-tested
  • Gives a close shave

CONS

  • Doesn’t wash off easily from the razor cartridge

8. Whish Lemongrass Shaving Cream

 Check The Best Price

The Best Shaving Cream For Stiff Joints and Achy Muscles

Enjoy a luxurious shave with the Whish Lemongrass Shaving Cream. This luscious cream is great for shaving the legs, bikini line, and underarms. It’s made of natural ingredients that will leave your skin feeling moisturized, nourished, and soothed than before.

Here are the features of the Whish Lemongrass Shaving Cream:

  • This shaving cream is enriched with lemongrass oil to help relieve stiff joints, enhance muscle tone, and soothe muscle pains. Other ingredients include natural squalene, organic green tea, organic coconut oil, and organic jojoba seed oil.
  • It contains no skin-irritating ingredients, such as paraben, petrochemical, and phthalate, making it safe for sensitive skin.
  • It’s Leaping Bunny Certified, meaning that it doesn’t test its product on animals.
  • It’s available in a pump bottle. The bottle pushes up from the bottom.

The only downside for this shaving cream is the bottle which has a pump that makes it hard to get the shaving cream out. It would be perfect if it came in a tube.

PROS​

  • Calming scent
  • Moisturizes and nourishes the skin
  • Relieves muscle pains
  • Feels light on the skin

CONS

  • Difficult to pump the shaving cream out

9. Now Solutions Nutri-Shave Natural Shave Cream

 Check The Best Price

The Best Shaving Cream For The Budget

If you have a limited budget, then the Nutri-Shave might be your best choice. An 8-ounce tube only costs less than $8. It’s specially made to decrease irritation and the development of ingrown hairs.

Here are some of Nutri-Shave’s features:

  • The Nutri-Shave fuses the soothing and protective benefits of Allantoin with the moisturizing effects of Hyaluronic Acid to provide an effective shave. It also contains potent natural ingredients, like aloe vera, coconut oil, and olive oil.
  • Its light formula tries to get rid of pore-clogging residue from your skin.
  • It has a light citrus aroma that delights the senses.
  • It’s vegan and contains no sulfates, making it gentle for sensitive skin.

As for the downside, the consistency is kind of a letdown because it’s very watery. It doesn’t stick to the skin so you need to apply more. 

PROS​

  • Has a pleasant scent
  • Very affordable
  • Made of natural ingredients
  • Good for most skin types

CONS

  • Runs off from the skin

10. IntiMD COOCHY PLUS Intimate Shave Cream

 Check The Best Price

​The Best Shaving Cream For The Intimate Area

Now, if you want a shaving cream especially for your intimate area, the IntiMD COOCHY PLUS might be heaven-sent for you. This shave cream is formulated with moisturizing and vitamin-rich ingredients that help fight inflammation and enhance your coochy shaving experience. It’s suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin.

Here are the features that make us love the IntiMD COOCHY PLUS:

  • It’s made of natural ingredients, such as jojoba oil, avocado oil, aloe vera, and shea butter. All these ingredients help fight inflammation and moisturize your skin.
  • This product uses Maca Root which is known for its aphrodisiac properties. It can help improve libido and improve sex life. It can also help ease a lot of menstrual symptoms.
  • While this product is specially made for the intimate area, it’s also good for other parts of the body, like the underarms.

The only downside of this shave cream is the added fragrance. If you’re sensitive to perfume, then this product isn’t for you. But if you’re only using it for your intimate area, then it’s no big deal.

PROS​

  • Moisturizes the skin
  • May improve libido
  • Smells very nice
  • Offers a close shave without razor bumps

CONS

  • Has added fragrance

The Buying Guide

Who Can Take Advantage Of The Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin?

You should consider using shaving cream for sensitive skin if you have:

  • Super dry skin
  • Acute skin conditions, like psoriasis and eczema
  • Acne-prone skin
  • Experienced serious razor bumps and ingrown hairs

What To Look For

1. Ingredients

When buying for the best shaving cream for your sensitive skin, the first thing that you need to check is the ingredient list. Make sure that it uses natural ingredients, like aloe, lemongrass, and coconut oil. Steer away from harsh chemicals, like phthalate and paraben.

Also, consider your allergies. If you’re allergic to gluten, make sure that the formula is gluten-free. Watch out for added fragrances if your skin is sensitive to artificial fragrances. The best shaving creams use natural scents from plant-derived ingredients.

2. Soothing Benefits

Sensitive skin is prone to skin irritation so you’ll want a shaving cream that soothes the skin. You can find it on the label of the product. If it says, “soothes” or ”soothing”, then that’s the tell-tale sign that the product offers great potential.

3. Fragrance-Free

As much as possible, ditch those shaving creams with added fragrance. Sometimes, those artificial fragrances can irritate the skin. What you want is a shaving cream that’s fragrance-free. Again, you can determine that on the product’s label.

4. Lather-Less Formula

While men need a thick lather to soften coarse hair, women need a rather lather-less formula. Women’s hair and skin are softer than men so they need a shaving cream that’s almost transparent. This helps in visibility and provide the right slickness to prevent irritation.

Shaving Tips For Sensitive Skin

  • Prep your skin - Wet your skin to soften the hair and makes it easier to cut. Apply the shaving cream and let it sit for a couple of minutes before you start shaving.
  • Exfoliate - Remove the dead skin cells that might get trapped on your skin. These dead skin cells can lead to razor bumps and ingrown hairs. For sensitive skin, exfoliate once or twice weekly.
  • Choose the right razor - If you want to use a disposable razor, pick a four or five blade razor. Consider using an electric razor if you easily develop ingrown hairs. For sensitive areas, use safety razors.
  • Go with the grain - Although shaving against the grain can give you a closer shave, it will be more irritating to sensitive skin. The best way to protect your skin from irritation is to shave in the same direction of the hair growth.

Which Is The Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin?

If we have to choose the best shaving cream for sensitive skin, Kiss My Face Moisture Shaving Cream surely beats the competition. This is made from the botanical blends of lemongrass and goldenseal, coconut oil, and olive oil. It’s free from phthalates, parabens, and artificial fragrances, making it great for sensitive skin.

What makes Kiss My Face stands out is its unique 4-in-formula that promises to soothe, moisturize, smoothe, and soften the skin. It comes in a 3.4-ounce tube which makes it easy to dispense and carry everywhere.

Leave a Comment